NYC Fashion Designer's Family Files $50M Lawsuit Over Montauk Boat Death, Accuses Companion

The family of Martha Nolan-O'Slatarra, a New York City fashion designer found dead on a boat in Montauk last year, is preparing to file a $50 million wrongful death lawsuit, according to NBC New York. The suit targets Christopher Durnan, the man who was with her when she died.
The lawsuit accuses Durnan of assault, gross negligence, and reckless conduct in connection with Nolan-O'Slatarra's death. Durnan has not been charged with any crimes. The Suffolk County Medical Examiner has not publicly released a final cause or manner of death, NBC DFW reported.
Nolan-O'Slatarra was a fashion designer based in New York City. She was found dead aboard a boat in the Hamptons area near Montauk. The exact circumstances of her death have not been made fully public. Her family says they want answers — and accountability.
The family's lawsuit names Christopher Durnan as the sole defendant. He was present with Nolan-O'Slatarra when she died. The suit charges him with assault, gross negligence, and reckless conduct. The family is seeking $50 million in damages, according to NBC Boston.
Despite the serious allegations, Durnan has not faced any criminal charges tied to her death. Civil lawsuits have a lower burden of proof than criminal cases. A family can sue for wrongful death even when no criminal charges are filed.
A key piece of the case remains unresolved. The Suffolk County Medical Examiner has not publicly released a final ruling on how Nolan-O'Slatarra died. Without an official cause and manner of death, the full picture of what happened on that boat is still unclear, NBC Chicago reported.
The lack of a public ruling is unusual given the time that has passed since her death. It may signal that the investigation is still active or that the findings are complex. The family's lawsuit could force more details into the public record through civil court proceedings.
The family is pushing ahead with a civil lawsuit even though no criminal case has been opened against Durnan. Civil suits allow families to seek financial damages when prosecutors have not acted. The $50 million figure reflects the severity of what the family alleges happened, according to NBC Miami.
The case draws attention at a time when high-profile deaths in wealthy vacation areas face scrutiny. Montauk and the broader Hamptons region are popular summer destinations for New York's elite. It is not yet clear when the lawsuit will formally be filed in court.
Publishers
11
Articles
11
Reach
11