New York Yankees Claim Series After Blue Jays Implode in Ninth Inning Again

The Toronto Blue Jays collapsed in the ninth inning for the second straight day, falling 8–3 to the New York Yankees at Rogers Centre on June 14, 2026. A throwing error by reliever Braydon Fisher opened the door, and the Yankees walked through it with a two-run homer from Ben Rice and a three-run shot from Jose Caballero — turning a 3–3 tie into an 8–3 blowout in minutes. The Canadian Press reported the loss leaves Toronto at 8–6–1 in home series this season.
New York improves to 43–27, first in the AL East. Toronto falls to 34–38. The Yankees claimed the three-game series two games to one, further widening the gap between the two division rivals.
The game was tied 3–3 heading into the ninth. Fisher started the inning and immediately ran into trouble. He committed a throwing error on a Paul Goldschmidt infield single, moving the runner to second. Ben Rice, who leads the Yankees with 19 home runs, then crushed a 381-foot two-run shot to give New York a 5–3 lead, according to Fort McMurray Today.
Jose Caballero followed with a three-run homer off Tommy Nance to make it 8–3. Caballero said post-game, "It's special to come to a place I've played for seasons and have this kind of performance." The Yankees scored five runs in the inning without a single defensive answer from Toronto. Fisher took the loss, dropping to 2–2 on the season.
Before the ninth-inning collapse, Blue Jays manager John Schneider was ejected in the eighth inning. Umpire Steven Jaschinski called a balk on reliever Jeff Hoffman with Jazz Chisholm Jr. on second base. Schneider argued loudly and was tossed — his 14th career ejection and second of the 2026 season, according to TSN. Associate manager DeMarlo Hale took over.
The balk call is part of a pattern for Schneider. He was also ejected on April 7 for arguing a balk call against Kevin Gausman. MLB has emphasized strict enforcement of Rule 6.02(a)(13) this season, which requires pitchers to come to a full stop in the set position. Toronto's pitching staff has been caught repeatedly. Some analysts say the calls are fair. Toronto fans and media say they are soft rulings that hurt the team's rhythm.
Toronto's brightest moment came in the sixth inning. Davis Schneider, recently recalled to the major league roster, hit a solo home run to center field off Yankees reliever Jake Bird. The blast tied the game at 3–3 and gave the Rogers Centre crowd something to cheer about. It was his second home run of the season, according to Owen Sound Sun Times.
Schneider has been one of the few productive pieces for a Blue Jays lineup missing key bats. Vladimir Guerrero Jr. (back) and Andrés Giménez (wrist) were both out of the lineup. Without those two, Toronto's offense leaned heavily on Kazuma Okamoto, who added an RBI single in the third to make it 2–1, per Brantford Expositor.
Will Warren started for New York and went four innings, giving up two runs on eight hits. He entered the game with a 7–1 record and a 3.41 ERA. He was not sharp, but he did his job. Camilo Doval then threw a perfect eighth inning with two strikeouts and earned the win, improving to 3–0, according to Vancouver Sun.
Toronto's Patrick Corbin lasted just 3.2 innings. He gave up seven hits and two earned runs. The Blue Jays needed their bullpen to eat innings — and it did not hold. Toronto now heads to Boston for a three-game series starting Tuesday. New York returns home to face the Chicago White Sox, with Gerrit Cole (1–1, 2.45 ERA) scheduled to start, per National Post.
Publishers
9
Articles
8
Reach
9