Jay-Z asks appeals court to revive extortion lawsuit after accuser recants allegations

Jay-Z has asked a California appeals court to reconsider its recent decision rejecting his extortion and defamation lawsuit against attorney Tony Buzbee, citing a sworn declaration in which Buzbee’s former client recanted her rape allegations. The woman said she had never met or spoken with Carter and that her accusations against him were false; her new lawyer also said she maintains she was sexually assaulted but mistakenly identified Carter. Carter argues the declaration undermines the reasoning behind the court’s earlier decision and warrants limited discovery so he can pursue his claims. The court had previously found insufficient evidence that Buzbee knowingly filed false allegations and said pre-lawsuit demand letters are a normal part of litigation. Buzbee has disputed that the demand letter amounted to extortion.
In her 11-page sworn declaration, signed in Alabama on Sept. 24 and filed in Manhattan federal court in a separate malicious-prosecution case, the woman said she had told one of her lawyers about mental-health conditions before Buzbee’s firm named Carter in the 2024 lawsuit.
The original lawsuit alleged that Carter and Sean “Diddy” Combs drugged and assaulted a 13-year-old girl at a 2000 after-party following the MTV Video Music Awards.
The California appeals court rejected Carter’s appeal on Sept. 9, before the woman’s recantation; his rehearing petition followed on Sept. 24.
Publishers
14
Articles
18
Reach
32