Yankees Rout White Sox 12-2 as Cole Shines, Unraveling Cy Young Candidate Martin

The White Sox’s quick collapse included defensive miscues: the Chicago Tribune reported that "Some defensive lapses by Chase Meidroth and Jacob Gonzalez opened the door" to the Yankees’ big early inning.
Despite the 12–2 score, New York squandered chances—Yahoo noted the Yankees "somehow still left 10 on base" and were "3-for-12 with runners in scoring position," suggesting the margin could have been even wider.
J.C. Escarra sparked the Yankees’ third-inning scoring with both a hit and an error: theScore/ AP coverage said Escarra "started the third with a double and reached three times, including on a throwing error by reliever Chris Murphy that gave the Yankees an 11-1 lead."
Aaron Judge’s injury context continued to ripple through the lineup—AP/theScore reported that Spencer Jones’ homer came off Martin, and it also highlighted that Jones "walked with the bases loaded during a four-run third after Martin lost an ABS challenge."
Off the field, the Yankees had a late-breaking availability update: NorthJersey reported that Jasson Dominguez "had an infected tooth extracted" earlier Tuesday and said he is "available off the bench" for that night’s game versus Chicago.
The New York Yankees dismantled the Chicago White Sox 12-2 on Tuesday at Yankee Stadium, tagging ace Davis Martin for nine runs in just 3 1/3 innings. It was Chicago's worst loss since Opening Day, and it wasn't close. theScore reported the Yankees improved to 8-4 since losing Aaron Judge to a stress fracture in his right rib.
Spencer Jones hit a two-run home run in the second inning. Ben Rice and Paul Goldschmidt each added two-run hits in a crushing fourth. Gerrit Cole was steady throughout, holding Chicago to two runs over six innings with seven strikeouts.
Martin entered Tuesday as one of the American League's best pitchers — 9-3 with a 2.41 ERA before the game. Things fell apart fast. Martin admitted that "things kind of unraveled pretty quickly," per Chicago Tribune. His ERA jumped from 2.41 to 3.31 after giving up nine earned runs. Three of New York's hits left the park.
A key turning point came in the third inning. Martin lost an Automated Ball-Strike (ABS) challenge — a system that lets players contest ball-and-strike calls — on a 3-2 count to Spencer Jones. The result was a bases-loaded walk. theScore noted that Martin's composure visibly slipped after the ruling, and the Yankees scored four runs in the frame.
The Yankees didn't just hit their way to 12 runs — Chicago handed several of them over. Chicago Tribune reported that "defensive lapses by Chase Meidroth and Jacob Gonzalez opened the door" to New York's big third inning. The Yankees scored four runs there on just two hits. The rest came via walks and miscues.
Utility player J.C. Escarra was at the center of the damage. He led off the third with a double, then reached three times total. theScore reported that a throwing error by reliever Chris Murphy on an Escarra grounder in the fourth gave New York its 11th run. Goldschmidt put it simply: "We're finding ways to bridge the gap while the big man is out."
Aaron Judge hasn't played since June 5, when he was diagnosed with a stress fracture in his right rib. Yet the Yankees finished with 16 hits and 12 runs. Jones, Rice, and Goldschmidt combined for most of the early damage. New York has now scored double-digit runs eight times during Judge's absence. The team went 8-4 in that stretch.
One roster wrinkle added to the day's drama. Outfielder Jasson Dominguez had an infected tooth removed Tuesday morning, NorthJersey reported. Manager Aaron Boone confirmed Dominguez was "available off the bench" by game time but would not start. The Yankees are also missing Giancarlo Stanton (calf) and Trent Grisham (hamstring), making every healthy body count.
Despite the blowout, New York's offense was far from clean. Yahoo Sports noted the Yankees "somehow still left 10 on base" and went just 3-for-12 with runners in scoring position. The final score of 12-2 was actually merciful — Chicago kept it from being worse only because New York repeatedly stalled with the bases loaded.
Chicago's manager Will Venable called the outing an "aberration" and pointed to Martin's recent track record — six shutout innings just three starts prior — as evidence this wasn't a long-term collapse. The White Sox had gone 32-19 since mid-April entering the series, per the research dossier, and they aren't ready to write off their season on one rough night.
Publishers
18
Articles
43
Reach
61