Mixed-Review Sequel
Practical Magic 2 Reunites Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman to Mixed Reviews
Anonymous
Key Points
1
The sequel is directed by Susanne Bier and draws from Alice Hoffman’s follow-up novel, “The Book of Magic,” with a screenplay credited to Akiva Goldsman, Georgia Pritchett and Kelly Marcel.
2
The film explains that Sally’s husband, Investigator Gary Hallet, died after marrying her, prompting Sally, Gillian and their aunts to conceal the family’s magical heritage from Sally’s daughters.
3
Kylie’s boyfriend Gideon, played by Xolo Maridueña, is struck by a car and falls into a coma after telling her he loves her; Kylie then investigates the family curse and travels to England to explore the Owens’ ancestral home.
4
The daughters have pursued conventional lives: Antonia is a trainee doctor while Kylie is an advanced arts student, reflecting Sally’s decision to raise them without knowledge of magic.
5
One review criticized the sequel’s 130-minute runtime as a major weakness, arguing that its rushed setup leaves unresolved questions about why the curse-breaking attempt failed and why the daughters cannot remember their magical childhood.
Nearly 30 years after the original became a cult favorite, "Practical Magic 2" reunites Sandra Bullock and Nicole Kidman as witch sisters Sally and Gillian Owens. The sequel shifts focus to Sally's adult daughters, Kylie and Antonia, when a family curse resurfaces after Sally's husband dies and Kylie's boyfriend falls into a coma. Stylist called it "the definition of a perfect sequel," while Townsville Bulletin said the film "has failed to impress its target audience."
Critics remain divided on the film's merits. Many praise the returning cast, sisterly themes, and cozy New England atmosphere. Others criticize its 130-minute runtime, overloaded plot, uneven tone, and predictable climax. The film is directed by Susanne Bier and adapted from Alice Hoffman's novel "The Book of Magic."
Why the Curse Returns After Decades of Silence
The sequel explains that Sally's first husband, Investigator Gary Hallet, died after marrying her. This triggered the family curse. Sally, Gillian, and their aunts then made a crucial decision: keep magic a secret from Sally's daughters. Kylie and Antonia grew up in the dark, pursuing conventional lives instead. Kylie became an advanced arts student. Antonia became a trainee doctor.
A Boyfriend's Accident Unleashes Family Secrets
The curse awakens when Kylie's boyfriend, Gideon (played by Xolo Maridueña), is struck by a car and falls into a coma. The timing is devastating—he told Kylie he loved her just before the accident. Desperate to save him, Kylie investigates her family's magical heritage. She travels to England to explore the Owens' ancestral home, seeking answers about the curse that threatens everyone she loves.
Critics Praise Heart but Question Pacing and Logic
Reviews highlight the chemistry between Bullock and Kidman and celebrate the film's exploration of sisterhood and family bonds. The New England setting adds warmth and charm. However, Herald Sun and other outlets note serious flaws. The 130-minute runtime feels bloated. Key plot holes remain unresolved—why did the curse-breaking attempt fail? Why can't the daughters remember their magical childhood? These questions linger without answers.
Courier Mail suggests the sequel appeals mainly to devoted franchise fans seeking nostalgia. Those who disliked the original are unlikely to be won over. The predictable climax and rushed setup undermine what could have been a stronger story. Mixed reviews indicate "Practical Magic 2" is a modest improvement over its predecessor—but not the transformative sequel some hoped for.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
15
Articles
44
Reach
59
Topics
A
AnonymousAuthor
