College Gap Year Dialogue
Expert Advises Parents on Thoughtfully Discussing a Gap Year with Their College-Bound 17-Year-Old
Key Points
Eric tells the parents their “concerns…are valid,” adding that the next step “may be well-received if you all look at this next step with intention, curiosity, honesty and clear eyes.”
Eric emphasizes the daughter isn’t just hearing the idea of college now—she’s “pretty far down the path,” and that she’s been “thinking about this for the better part of a year,” after “considered colleges, applied, and then been accepted.”
Rather than debating the gap-year logistics immediately, Eric instructs: “Start the conversation by asking if she agrees that the issues may cause difficulty.”
In the same column issue, Eric’s advice appears alongside another reader note that references his earlier guidance about a different case—“the grandfather who was funding his granddaughter’s less-than-impressive college experience (‘Funding Granddad’).”
A 17-year-old has committed to an out-of-state university and refuses to discuss a gap year — and her parents don't know how to break through. Asking Eric columnist R. Eric Thomas says the parents' "concerns are valid," but warns that pushing too hard could backfire badly.
Thomas, who writes the syndicated advice column, says the daughter has spent "the better part of a year" on this goal. She has "considered colleges, applied, and then been accepted." Any gap-year push now can feel like her effort is being thrown away, Asking Eric notes.
Why Parents Feel Shut Down Every Time They Ask
The parents write that every time they raise the gap-year topic, the conversation shuts down fast. Thomas explains why: the daughter is not hearing this idea fresh. She is "pretty far down the path." Months of applications, essays, and acceptances are already behind her. A gap year sounds like a punishment, not a plan.
Thomas tells the parents to stop debating logistics first. Instead, he says, "start the conversation by asking if she agrees that the issues may cause difficulty." That small shift moves the parents from being opponents to being allies, Asking Eric explains.
A Gap Year Won't Fix Problems Without a Clear Plan
Thomas cautions that a gap year is not a magic fix. If the family cannot name what she would actually do for those 12 months, the time off often leads to stagnation, not growth. The specific worries driving the parents' hesitation must be spelled out first.
About 3% to 7% of American students take a gap year before college, according to the Gap Year Association. And roughly 30% of college freshmen do not return for their sophomore year, a figure that shows why readiness matters. But Thomas says the answer is not always to delay — it is to prepare.
Practical Alternatives to Simply Staying Home
If the core worry is maturity or readiness, Thomas offers concrete options short of a full gap year. He suggests finding a mentor — an older student she can talk to. He also recommends joining a local sports team or club to build social skills before she leaves.
Another option: connect her with a family friend who lives near the campus. That person can be a local support system without hovering over her. Thomas frames these as "scaffolding" — support structures that give her independence while reducing the risk of failure alone far from home.
The 'Funding Granddad' Warning Lurking Behind This Story
In the same column issue, Thomas references an earlier case: "Funding Granddad," a grandfather who paid for his granddaughter's "less-than-impressive college experience." That case is a cautionary tale. Out-of-state tuition averages around $29,150 per year. If a student is not ready and fails out, the financial loss is real and immediate.
Thomas says the goal is what he calls a "co-authored" outcome. The parents name the real concerns. The daughter agrees those concerns could create problems. Then together they decide how to set her up for success — whether she goes now or waits. He urges the family to move forward with "intention, curiosity, honesty and clear eyes."
Sentiment
Mostly NegativePublishers
10
Articles
23
Reach
33
