Belichick Broncos Coaching 'What If'
Sean Payton Reportedly Floated Bold Plan for Bill Belichick to Coach Denver Broncos Temporarily
Key Points
Belichick reportedly provided Payton with bullet points he used to motivate his Patriots teams, a detail Payton reportedly drew on when considering the Broncos plan.
The proposed arrangement would have had Payton step aside as Broncos head coach and run the offense as assistant head coach while Belichick coached until he reached a milestone win total; the idea was deemed too complicated and never formally offered.
Belichick left the Patriots after the 2023 season and later became the head coach of the University of North Carolina, signaling the end of any NFL return tied to Payton's proposal.
Belichick remains second on the NFL's all-time wins list behind Don Shula; the hypothetical plan would have given him a path to surpass Shula if it had been pursued in Denver.
Sean Payton once floated a remarkable idea: let Bill Belichick take over as Denver Broncos head coach — temporarily — so Belichick could chase Don Shula's all-time NFL wins record. According to ESPN, Payton would step aside, serve as assistant head coach, and run the offense while Belichick coached until he collected 15 more wins to surpass Shula's record of 347 career victories.
The plan never left the drawing board. It was deemed too complicated to pull off, and Belichick ultimately left the NFL after the 2023 season to become head coach at the University of North Carolina. But the story, reported by ESPN's Seth Wickersham, offers a rare window into the deep relationship between two of football's most respected coaches.
The Unusual Plan Payton Considered for 2024
The idea targeted the 2024 season. Payton would hand over the head coaching title to Belichick, then take it back once Belichick hit the milestone win total. Payton would still run the offense as assistant head coach during that stretch. Fox News reported that the plan required Belichick's consent and likely a multi-year commitment, two factors that made it hard to execute.
SI.com noted that Wickersham's reporting frames the whole idea as an intriguing "what if" — a plan that was considered seriously enough to think through, but never formally offered to Belichick. The proposal would have flipped the normal coaching structure entirely, with the sitting head coach essentially becoming a subordinate to help a colleague make history.
Belichick's Record Chase and Why It Matters
Belichick finished his NFL career second on the all-time wins list. Shula sits at the top with 347 wins. Belichick needs just 15 more to break that record. Under Payton's plan, those 15 wins would come in Denver — a scenario that would have made Belichick the winningest coach in NFL history without returning to the Patriots.
NY Post reported that the idea grew from the genuine respect Payton has for Belichick. Both coaches came up under Bill Parcells, and Payton reportedly used bullet points Belichick gave him — notes Belichick used to motivate his Patriots teams — when thinking through the Denver proposal. That personal history made the plan feel possible, even if the logistics made it impractical.
Belichick Heads to College; Payton Reaches the Postseason
Instead of returning to the NFL, Belichick took the head coaching job at the University of North Carolina. That move effectively closed the door on any arrangement tied to Payton's proposal. Head Topics reported that once Belichick made the jump to college football, the chance for him to chase Shula's record in the pros faded with it.
Meanwhile, Payton kept leading the Broncos. Denver reached the postseason in 2024, giving Payton his own milestone moment in Colorado. The Broncos' turnaround under Payton made the idea of handing the reins to anyone else — even Belichick — feel all the more unlikely in hindsight. The whole episode now stands as one of the NFL's most fascinating plans that never happened.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativePublishers
34
Articles
69
Reach
103
