Blue Jays Ace Dylan Cease Misses Start Due to Shoulder Fatigue

Cease signed a seven-year, partially deferred $210 million contract with Toronto during the offseason, the largest pitching contract in Blue Jays franchise history.
Cease was selected to start the 2026 All-Star Game and remains a strong Cy Young candidate despite his second-half decline.
Toronto has had only three healthy starting pitchers for most of the past month, with Shane Bieber and Trey Yesavage sidelined; Yesavage is scheduled to start Monday against Baltimore.
Manager John Schneider said Cease had been dealing with the shoulder issue for at least several weeks and described the situation as shoulder fatigue, while adding, “Not expecting anything crazy” from the MRI results.
Cease’s average fastball velocity has fallen from 99 mph in his first start of the season to below 95 mph in each of his last two outings, reinforcing that the decline has developed over multiple starts rather than appearing only in Friday’s game.
Toronto Blue Jays ace Dylan Cease will miss his scheduled start against Baltimore after an MRI revealed shoulder fatigue, leaving the team awaiting further results. CBS Sports confirmed Cease does not need surgery, but his immediate playing status remains unclear as Clutch Points noted the team is still analyzing MRI findings on his throwing shoulder.
The injury comes at a critical time for Toronto, which sits 76-78 with eight games left and trails the final American League wild-card spot by roughly three games. Manager John Schneider said Mahoning Matters that the shoulder issue has persisted for several weeks, adding "Not expecting anything crazy" from the test results.
Cease's fastball has lost velocity over recent weeks. His four-seamer averaged 99 mph in his season opener but dropped below 95 mph in each of his last two starts. In his most recent outing against Texas, he threw a career-low 90.0 mph fastball while lasting just 2.2 innings and allowing four runs.
The Blue Jays have had only three healthy starting pitchers for most of the past month. Shane Bieber remains sidelined, and Trey Yesavage is scheduled to start Monday against Baltimore. Cease's absence creates another gap in a rotation already stretched thin during the final stretch of the season.
Despite his recent decline, Cease has posted elite numbers this season: a 2.40 ERA, 1.10 WHIP, and an American League-leading 239 strikeouts. KTIK reported that Cease may be done for the season, but manager Schneider has not ruled out his return for Toronto's final series against Cincinnati if the team remains in contention.
Cease signed a seven-year, partially deferred $210 million deal with Toronto during the offseason — the largest pitching contract in franchise history. He was selected to start the 2026 All-Star Game. Any extended absence or season-ending injury would represent a significant setback for both the pitcher and the team's investment.
Publishers
13
Articles
60
Reach
73