Brewers Bench Rookie
Milwaukee Brewers Manager Pat Murphy Benches Rookie Cooper Pratt For Lack Of Hustle
Anonymous
Key Points
1
Murphy has used midgame benchings as a broader discipline tool, previously pulling Sal Frelick for missing the cutoff man and Caleb Durbin for getting picked off, and even yanking starting pitchers Brandon Sproat and Robert Gasser in separate games this month.
2
The Pratt benching included the use of pinch-runner David Hamilton, who later contributed to the game’s fate by committing a walk-off throwing error at third base in the 10th inning.
3
Pratt is a 22-year-old rookie who made his major league debut on June 16, roughly 2 1/2 months before the benching, highlighting his limited big‑league experience.
4
In the third-inning at-bat, Pratt was asked to bunt, fouled off the first pitch, pulled back his bunt on the second pitch, and then fouled off two more pitches before grounding back to the pitcher.
5
During the fifth inning, Pratt hit a fly ball to shallow right, paused in the batter’s box to look skyward, and then ran; the ball dropped between three Mets fielders, and he would have easily reached second base.
Milwaukee Brewers manager Pat Murphy benched rookie shortstop Cooper Pratt midgame during a 3-2, 10-inning loss to the New York Mets, sending a stark message about hustle and focus. ClutchPoints reported that Pratt failed to run hard out of the batter's box on a bloop single in the fifth inning and earlier pulled back his bunt sign in the third, prompting Murphy to replace him with a pinch-runner.
Murphy made clear the benching was not about laziness but accountability. MLB.com noted that the manager said Pratt "has no excuses" and stressed that as a young player still developing power, the rookie must execute effort plays to stay in the lineup. The episode became a teaching moment for the entire roster about Murphy's unwavering standards for "winning baseball."
A Pattern of Midgame Discipline from Murphy
The Pratt benching fits Murphy's broader approach to roster accountability this season. WBAL reported that Murphy has previously pulled outfielder Sal Frelick for missing a cutoff man and yanked infielder Caleb Durbin for getting picked off. The manager also removed starting pitchers Brandon Sproat and Robert Gasser in separate games this month, signaling that no player—regardless of status—escapes consequences for mental errors.
Murphy's message is consistent: mistakes born from lack of focus hurt the team's push for a deep playoff run. The Brewers boast one of baseball's best records, making every game and every at-bat crucial. Pratt acknowledged his mistakes and apologized, vowing it won't happen again.
Two Critical Mistakes in One At-Bat
Pratt's benching stemmed from two separate plays that exposed a lack of urgency. In the third inning, ESPN reported that Pratt was asked to bunt, fouled off the first pitch, then pulled back his bunt sign on the second pitch before fouling off two more pitches and grounding back to the pitcher. The entire sequence lacked the sharp focus Murphy demands.
Two innings later, Pratt hit a fly ball to shallow right field. ClutchPoints noted he paused in the batter's box to look skyward before running—a half-second delay that nearly cost him. The ball dropped between three Mets fielders, and he would have easily reached second base if he had run hard immediately.
A Pinch-Runner's Error Seals the Loss
The benching set up an ironic twist in the game's final outcome. MLB.com reported that David Hamilton, the pinch-runner who replaced Pratt, later committed a walk-off throwing error at third base in the 10th inning—the play that handed the Mets victory. The loss stung, but Murphy used it to reinforce his broader point about execution and alertness.
Pratt is a 22-year-old who made his major league debut on June 16, giving him limited big-league experience as he navigates Murphy's high standards. The manager's willingness to bench him sends a signal to the entire roster: age and inexperience are no shield against accountability. Every player must bring full effort, every inning, every at-bat.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativeNEGATIVENEUTRALPOSITIVE
Publishers
16
Articles
126
Reach
142
A
AnonymousAuthor
