Soto's Baserunning Blunder
Juan Soto Draws Fan Criticism for Baserunning Blunder During Mets-Phillies Game
Juan Soto, baseball's highest-paid player at $765 million over 15 years, became the target of sharp mockery on Sunday after a botched baserunning attempt in the Mets' 6-2 loss to the Philadelphia Phillies. Sportskeeda reported that Soto tried to stretch a single into a double in the third inning but was thrown out comfortably, while his team was already trailing 5-1.
The blunder set off a wave of jokes on X, formerly Twitter. One viral post summed up the mood: "He tried to pull the Bryce Harper but lacked the Aura required to do so," according to Sportskeeda. The mockery stings because Phillies star Bryce Harper had just completed the most dominant two days of the series — a cycle on Saturday and a home run on Sunday.
Harper and Schwarber Dominate the Weekend Series
The backdrop made Soto's mistake hit harder. On Saturday, June 20, Harper became just the latest player to hit for a cycle — recording a single, double, triple, and home run in one game. Kyle Schwarber added three home runs of his own in a 15-3 blowout. The Phillies beat the Mets 6-2 again on Sunday, with both Harper and Schwarber going deep a second straight game, according to The Morning Call.
The Phillies won the series convincingly. Their lineup drew a sharp contrast with a Mets offense that struggled to respond. The 41,552 fans at Citizens Bank Park had plenty to cheer about — and plenty to heckle Soto about.
The "Aura" Gap Fans Can't Stop Talking About
Social media framed the caught stealing as more than a baserunning error. Fans called Soto "the most overrated player in the MLB" and "an awful baserunner," according to Sportskeeda. The core argument: Soto tried an aggressive, risky play — the kind Harper pulls off — but without the clutch presence, or "aura," to back it up. Harper is a two-time MVP with multiple deep playoff runs. Soto, despite his elite stats, plays for a team sitting at 34-41, the third-worst record in the National League.
During the game, a Phillies fan heckled Soto with obscene gestures from the stands. Soto reportedly stared him down for several seconds without reacting, until stadium officials stepped in. That moment, too, got clipped and shared widely — framed as either composure or defiance, depending on who you asked.
Soto's Stats Are Elite — but His Baserunning Is a Problem
The criticism is not about Soto's bat. He is hitting .300 with a .980 OPS, 17 home runs, and 38 RBI through June 21. He is also the seventh player in MLB history to reach 200 career home runs before age 26. But his baserunning has become a recurring issue. Earlier this month, on June 6, he drew backlash for failing to run out a fumble against the Padres, killing a scoring chance in a "lazy" play, according to Sportskeeda.
Some analysts have floated the idea of moving Soto to designated hitter full-time to remove his baserunning and defensive exposure as liabilities. Mets manager Carlos Mendoza has already shifted Soto to left field full-time. Mendoza has defended Soto publicly, saying he shows leadership "behind the scenes" and "doesn't want to do it in front of the cameras."
$765 Million Makes Every Mistake a Bigger Story
Soto's contract is the largest in professional sports history — 15 years, $765 million, with no deferred money, signed in December 2024. That deal now occupies roughly 20% of the Mets' theoretical salary cap space under proposed new MLB rules. With the team underperforming at 34-41, every visible mistake gets amplified. One bad jump on the basepaths becomes a referendum on whether he is worth the investment, according to Sportskeeda.
Mets president of baseball operations David Stearns faces growing pressure to build a winning roster around Soto before 2027. His deal has already shifted the entire MLB salary market — influencing a $500 million extension for Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and setting benchmarks for upcoming free agents. But none of that matters to Phillies fans celebrating a series win and a rival's stumble.
Sentiment
NeutralPublishers
5
Articles
3
Reach
5
