New Evidence in Murder Case
Prosecutors Disclose New Evidence in Karmelo Anthony’s Bid for a Murder Retrial
Key Points
Prosecutors presented a text in which Anthony allegedly wrote, 'When I stab somebody, I’m gonna lick their blood off the blade,' and showed a photo of a knife along with a separate message 'I’m lowkey on the verge,' illustrating a documented pattern of violence toward blades, guns and fights found on his phone.
The proceedings disclosed a 'gentleman’s agreement' that kept Metcalf’s juvenile history out of the original trial, including Metcalf’s juvenile record which prosecutors say included graffiti described as 'vile racist stuff.'
A replacement judge, Retired Judge Michael Chitty, was assigned to the case after bias concerns about Judge John Roach; Chitty has until August 24 to decide on the motion for a new trial.
The stabbing occurred hours after a report that Anthony’s ex-girlfriend said he was stalking her, and prosecutors described the fatal act as taking place under a tent at a Frisco track meet over a seating dispute, highlighting the context of escalating behavior.
Prosecutors revealed disturbing evidence in Karmelo Anthony's murder retrial that jurors in his original trial never saw. Hours before he fatally stabbed 17-year-old Austin Metcalf at a Frisco track meet in 2025, Anthony's ex-girlfriend reported he was stalking her and sent threatening messages about knives and violence. People reported that Anthony texted a fantasy about stabbing someone and licking blood off the blade—a detail that could have shaped the jury's verdict in the original case.
The hidden evidence emerged during a hearing as Anthony appeals his 35-year murder sentence. Prosecutors blamed a "gentleman's agreement" with the defense for keeping the material out of the original trial. A new judge, Retired Judge Michael Chitty, has been assigned to decide whether Anthony deserves a new trial by August 24. Daily Wire noted that the prosecutor revealed a statement from Anthony's ex-girlfriend alongside the disturbing texts.
A Pattern of Obsession With Violence
Anthony's phone contained a trove of troubling material, according to prosecutors. Twitchy reported that Anthony wrote, "When I stab somebody, I'm gonna lick their blood off the blade." He also sent a photo of a knife to his ex-girlfriend along with a message saying, "I'm lowkey on the verge." These texts painted a picture of someone spiraling toward violence in the hours before Metcalf died.
The stalking complaint from Anthony's ex happened the same day as the stabbing. Megyn Kelly stated that prosecutors described Anthony as fixated on weapons, violence, and confrontation. The timeline showed escalation: harassment in the morning, then the fatal stabbing by afternoon under a tent over a seating dispute at the track meet.
Why the Original Jury Never Heard It
A "gentleman's agreement" between prosecutors and the defense kept key evidence sealed from jurors. US Head Topics reported that prosecutors revealed troves of material, including the disturbing texts and ex-girlfriend statements, that the original jury never saw. Neither side formally objected to keeping the evidence out. The hidden material could have influenced how jurors weighed Anthony's character and state of mind.
The agreement also meant jurors did not learn about Metcalf's juvenile history. Prosecutors said Metcalf's juvenile record included graffiti described as "vile racist stuff." Both sides chose to keep this information private, even though it might have affected how the jury viewed Metcalf and the context of the conflict.
Judge Change and Next Steps in Appeals
The original judge, John Roach, was replaced due to bias concerns. Retired Judge Michael Chitty now oversees the case. Daily Wire reported that Chitty must decide by August 24 whether the new evidence warrants a fresh trial. Anthony's legal team argues the hidden material proves his trial was unfair or that prosecutors violated his rights.
The retrial fight centers on a simple question: Does hidden evidence change the case? Prosecutors say the disturbing texts show Anthony was dangerous and obsessed with violence. The defense counters that the trial process itself was flawed. The outcome could reshape how courts handle evidence disclosure and sealed agreements between prosecutors and defense teams.
Sentiment
Mostly NegativePublishers
10
Articles
4
Reach
14
